UK Supreme court rules Uber drivers are not self-employed

Uber’s workforce must now be classified as ‘workers’ rather than ‘self-employed’, the Supreme Court has ruled in a landmark employment tribunal.

UK Supreme court rules Uber drivers are not self-employed

Uber appealed to the Supreme Court after having lost three previous cases. This final ruling by the Supreme Court marks the end of a long-running tribunal, preventing Uber from any further appeals. 

This ruling could mean that many thousands of Uber’s drivers might be entitled to minimum wage and holiday pay, something traditionally reserved for those under PAYE employment, as well as exposing Uber to potentially significant historical compensation claims.

The Supreme Court considered a number of employment law elements, which ultimately led it to the conclusion that the drivers were not truly self-employed. 

-       Uber set the drivers’ fares, which meant they were limiting how much drivers could earn.

-       Uber decided the contract terms and the drivers had no option other than to accept those terms.

-       Drivers did not have the ability to reject rides without being penalised.

-       Uber had the ability to terminate the relationship with a driver if their ratings dropped too low.

-       Uber actively monitored drivers to prevent them from forming a direct agreement with a passenger outside of the app.

 

This case underlines the necessity of engaging with self-employed people in a manner that reflects the contract agreed. In other words, a contract alone is not enough to protect employment status from scrutiny. The reality of working conditions must be demonstrated to match that of the contract.

Although this has far-reaching consequences for the gig economy, it needn’t impact those who operate a truly self-employed model. 

Satisfy the key requirements of engaging with the self-employed, and ensure that the contract and reality are aligned, and you will have no cause for concern.

However, if you are worried about the current model you’re using with self-employed people. Then IN-SYNC Group can provide an audit of your current processes, highlighting risk areas, and making suggestions for how best to negate those risks. 



Contact us to arrange a self-employed status audit

WEBINAR - IR35: What your company needs to know

31 January 2021

IN-SYNC Group will be hosting Industry expert Alex Baines to demystify the upcoming changes to IR35. If you are unsure of how these changes will impact your business then Alex will help you understand exactly what you need to do. 

UK political parties pledge IR35 review

06 December 2019

The general election fast approaching. Self-employment has been high on the agenda, with several key political figures suggesting a review of off-payroll rules may well be on the horizon.

IR35 confusion could only get worse according to IPSE

09 October 2019

GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) has been at the heart of an HMRC crackdown as almost 1,500 self-employed contractors are accused of being “disguised employees” under new IR35 rules. IPSE, one of the UK’s leading associations for self-employed, has warned that this confusion is “only a taste of things to come”.


Show more